Google recently implemented a new feature for their popular map service called “street viewâ€. Using it you can have a ground level panoramic view of streets and neighborhoods. Currently it is only available for a few major cities (San Francisco Bay area, Las Vegas, Denver, Miami, and New York City) but I’m sure that more are on the way. In fact the Volkswagen Bug with its roof mounted cameras has already been spotted in Washington, D.C. In an odd twist of fate a blogger took a picture of the car taking pictures of Washington. Immersive Media is the company Google contracted to produce the digital images of cities around the country – other than San Francisco, which Google did itself.
The resolution of many images are clear enough to make out faces, license plates, and cats sitting on window sills. I was able to locate the house I lived in as a young child in San Jose, CA and the clarity is stunning. Having something personal show up in this publicly available service really drives home the issue of privacy. As all of the images were taken in public spaces there does not seem to be any legal questions to consider. However there are certainly ethical issues we must think about.
If a person was captured in a digital image there is a good chance that we can make out his face. Google did not take any measure to protect the privacy of individuals by perhaps blurring their faces. Certainly legal, but ethical? Kevin Bankston, a privacy advocate for the Electronic Frontier Foundation often shares his personal story of being caught on camera by another now defunct service smoking outside his work place – a habit he had been trying to hide from his family. Whether his case is a critical one isn’t important, it is the principal that matters. Even though it is entirely up to chance whether you are caught on camera or not, it is certainly possible to caught doing something you might want to keep legitimately hidden. Google did have the foresight to remove women’s shelters from the service before launch.
Even if we accept Google’s street view feature as is, we need to be concerned about what similar services might appear in the future. I spend a lot of time in Washington and I know that there are security cameras all over town. Will the next step be to have real time images on a Google Maps-like service? I may not have much faith in the objectivity of our government, but I certainly don’t want my movements to be traceable by any John, Jane or Joe who has a decent internet connection.
As it is right now, I must admit that I am looking forward to the day Google adds Washington to its street view service. The ability to scope out unfamiliar businesses and location before metro their sure will be handy. I just hope I don’t find myself in a compromising situation for all of the world to see.